OSOD Testifies on Senate Education Interim Charge: Senate Bill 2 TEFA Voucher Program

Public Testimony to the Senate Education Committee

Interim Charge on Senate Bill 2 TEFA Voucher Program

October 7, 2026

I’m Dee Carney, Director of the Texas Center for Voucher Transparency, which is an initiative of Our Schools Our Democracy. Good policy requires great information. Before the Legislature considers expanding taxpayer funding for the TEFA program from $1 billion to potentially $4.4 billion, there are two important considerations for lawmakers:

First: Vouchers have a public-school price tag.

We analyzed Comptroller-reported counts of students who were previously enrolled in Texas public schools and left for private schools or homeschool using TEFA vouchers. As of August 10, the data shows 733 public school districts losing an estimated $294 million in WADA-based revenue this school year.

And because fixed costs remain when students leave, that creates budget challenges for all 733 school districts – but especially for rural districts.

As one superintendent told the Houston Chronicle, in his district of 500 students, losing four students to vouchers means losing a teacher’s salary.

Second: Before expanding the TEFA program, evaluate it.

There is a reporting gap in SB2. It requires an annual longitudinal report, but also says it must cover at least five years. Statute does not explain how these requirements work together—and that ambiguity matters.

Before committing billions more in taxpayer funds, Texans want to know whether this program is delivering on its’ promises this school year, not five years from now.

We’ve provided revenue loss estimates for the school districts in your Senate district in your handouts.

Thank you, Madame Chair and members.