Charters and Consequences: An Investigative Series

Report by Network for Public Education

In 1988, American Federation of Teachers President, Al Shanker, voiced his support for charter schools. His hope was that a new school model, judiciously used, could be an incubator of innovation. Freed from district rules and red tape, charters would be a place where teachers could try new approaches with hard to reach kids, and then share what worked (or did not) with their neighborhood public school.

However, as Network for Public Education President, Diane Ravitch, reminds us, by 1993 Al Shanker became disillusioned. He turned against the schools whose name he coined. Shanker saw what charters had become—a privatized system run not by teachers, but rather by both non-profit and for-profit corporations who believed that schooling was a business rather than a community responsibility. Instead of supporting and sharing practices with neighborhood schools, most charters were rivals that sought to attract the most motivated families and the most compliant children.

How charter schools have exponentially expanded since Al Shanker’s passing in 1997 is astounding. It is estimated that more than three million American children are now educated in charter schools, which exist in 44 states and the District of Columbia.

There are national chains that are corporately managed and “mom and pop” charters. There is instability as charters open and close. About 1 in 5 are for-profit. Some have a real estate arm that buys buildings then rents them to their own schools at exorbitant rates. Still others are not-for-profit fronts that are managed by for-profit corporations.

Some charters are brick and mortar, others are located in storefronts and still others are cyber or virtual schools. Charter holders include teachers, economists, rap stars and retired tennis players. Many boards are populated by billionaires who enjoy isolated lives of wealth far from the poor, urban communities their “no-excuses” charters serve.

And nearly every day brings a story, often reported only in local newspapers, about charter mismanagement, failure, nepotism or outright theft and fraud.